Do SAT Subject Tests Actually Matter?

Do SAT Subject Tests Actually Matter?

30 November, 2020

Junior year in high school is fraught. It’s the most important year in terms of academics. It’s when you take the SAT or ACT, when you start putting together your college list, and when you are likely hitting your peak in whatever sports or extra-curricular activities you’re involved in. In short, it’s probably the most stressful year you’ll experience until after you’ve graduated from college.

Into that mix, you need to add the often poorly understood SAT subject tests --formerly known as SAT II and not to be confused with AP exams (advanced placement exams), also created by College Board. While most people have at least heard of the SAT, the ACT, or even both, a surprising number of people aren’t even aware that the SAT Subject Tests exist, and even those who do know aren’t sure whether they need to take them, or when, or which ones. Some of the most popular SAT Subject Tests are Biology E/M, Math II, US History, World History, and Physics, but others include Italian, English Language, Latin, Korean, Modern Hebrew and several others.

So without further ado, here’s your introduction to the SAT Subject Tests:

What Are The Subject Tests?

The Subject Tests are a series of one-hour exams that focus on a variety of academic subjects. They ask multiple choice questions and produce a score on a scale of 200 to 800. For more details and a list of subjects, check out this page on the College Board website.

Do I Need to Take Subject Tests?

This is the first question most people have. The answer is: It depends on where you’re applying to school. In years past, schools like California Institute of Technology, Georgetown University, Duke University, and Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) required subject tests.  There were others that recommended or considered SAT Subject Tests.  As of March 2020, there are no colleges or universities in the United States that require Subject Tests for admission but there are specific programs that do. You can find that list here. If you plan to apply to any program that requires or recommends SAT Subject Test scores, you should absolutely take the required (or recommended) number of SAT Subject Tests. Make sure you examine the stated policy of each school; this list is really just a starting point. For example, many engineering schools require both Math II and one of the Science tests.

Also, some schools don’t require Subject Tests if you take the ACT, so if you plan to take the ACT, you should look into that policy at the schools you’re considering.

When Should I Take Subject Tests?

First of all, in a perfect world, you’d be asking me this question freshman year. Why? Because, depending on the subject, freshman year might be the best year to take the test. You should take a Subject Test at the end of the academic year that you complete the relevant coursework. Interested in taking Biology? If your coursework in Biology is freshman year, that’s when you should take the test so plan your test prep and practice tests accordingly.

All other things being equal, you should try to have at least a first crack at the Subject Tests by the end of your junior year; lots of students save the June test date for exactly that purpose.

Two other important considerations: Subject Tests are given on the same days as the SAT (except the March test date, which is SAT only), so make sure to plan appropriately. Also, language tests with listening are only given in November. Plan ahead accordingly.

Which Tests Should I Take?

Obviously, you want the tests that will make the best impression. What does that mean?

1. If the school has particular requirements (or even recommendations), follow them. Some schools require particular tests (usually the Math Level 2 and/or a Science for engineering programs). Other schools require that your two tests be from different “areas” (the areas are usually defined as math, science, humanities, and foreign language). In short, make sure you’re aware of any particular requirements.

2. Math Level 1 usually doesn’t fly at top schools. If you’re applying to one of the very top schools, the Math Level 1 will be considered a real weakness. Only take it if you have no other options.

3. Consider the message you want to send. Your choice of subject tests defines your academic strengths. Math + Science sends a very different message than Language + Literature, though both define you as a specialist. Want to show breadth? Go for Math or Science + Language/Literature/History.

4. Showcase your strengths. The bottom line is that you want to take the tests that will produce the best scores for you. This should trump most other considerations (except, of course, explicit instructions from a school).

5. If you are a native speaker, don’t take the language test! College admissions officers aren’t dumb. No one is impressed by a native speaker of Spanish or German knocking it out of the park on the Spanish or German Subject Test.

What Matters: The Percentile or the Score?

This is a tough question to answer, actually. Let’s consider how this works using my favorite test: the Math Level 2.

As of the most recent released statistics, a perfect score on the Math Level 2 is only the 83rd percentile. This has, over the years, led to any number of freak-outs and, frankly, a lot of bad advice. I’ve heard tutors who I very much respect claim “this means if you can’t break insert number greater than 750 here, you shouldn’t take the Math Level 2!”

As my grandfather would have said: piffle.

Why is a “perfect score” only the 83rd percentile? You have to think about who is taking this test: people applying to the absolute top engineering schools in the country. Top math students applying to highly competitive schools. If a lot of these students weren’t strong enough at math to garner a perfect score, something would be wrong. SAT subject tests are, quite simply, curved differently. For the most part, just worry about getting scores that are roughly numerically equivalent to your SAT scores (or, if you took the ACT, to the average SAT scores for your school).

Summing Up

Find out what the schools you’re applying to require in terms of SAT Subject Tests, schedule them when you’ll be most ready to take them (usually at the end of the relevant academic year), and take the tests the will present the best picture to the admissions committee.

SAT Subject Tests
About the Author
Dan Edmonds
Noodle Pro Dan Edmonds has 20 years of tutoring experience. He has led R&D for two major test prep companies, written or contributed to innumerable test prep and admissions books, trained or...

Standardized exam on the horizon? Thinking about supplemental academic tutoring? Our Education Specialists can help navigate you towards success with a free 1:1 consult.

Noodle Pros tutors are full-time test prep and academic tutors with no less than seven years of experience. Qualifying to become a Pro is no easy task, and we take qualifying tutors seriously. Schedule a meeting below, and we will send an email to prepare you for your consultation. We’ll only call you that day. And no, we won’t share your info with anyone else unless you ask us to.

Use the calendar below to schedule a free 30-minute call.